Day Hospital in Community Psychiatry: Is it Still an Alternative to Mental Health Care? Rui Lopes 1, Rosário Curral 1,2 - PDF

218 ARTIGO Day Hospital in Community Psychiatry: Is it Still an Alternative to Mental Health Care? Rui Lopes 1, Rosário Curral 1,2 ABSTRACT The Day Hospital constitutes one of the main components of the

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 6
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.


Publish on:

Views: 19 | Pages: 6

Extension: PDF | Download: 0

218 ARTIGO Day Hospital in Community Psychiatry: Is it Still an Alternative to Mental Health Care? Rui Lopes 1, Rosário Curral 1,2 ABSTRACT The Day Hospital constitutes one of the main components of the community psychiatry and it is integrated in the current social psychiatry policy, representing one of the main alternatives to inpatient regimen. The concept was created in ex-urss in the 1930 s and spread to USA during the 40 s and 50 s, reaching its peak in the 1970 s. Even though there was in the decades ahead a decline of expansion and an increased closure of day hospital programs, there has been in the last few years, a renewed interest as well as an increased number of established day hospitals. Although this phenomenon is related to evidence of cost effectiveness and social advantage, showing that they can provide feasible and effective care, new paradigms like acute home care can make it seem old fashionable and aged. Nowadays, a more intensive treatment and an increasing number of therapeutic models applied to different psychiatric disorders, settled by a modern community mental health care system, are becoming the reality of its practice. But the somehow heterogeneity of the community services that the designation day hospital comprises can make difficult the evaluation of its efficacy. The purpose of this review is to find out what is the position of day hospital in the context of actual and future mental health care. KEY-WORDS: Day hospital; Community psychiatry; Mental health Hospital de Dia em Psiquiatria Comunitária: Continua a Ser Uma Alternativa nos Cuidados de Saúde Mental? RESUMO O Hospital de Dia constitui um dos principais componentes da psiquiatria comunitária e está integrado na actual política de psiquiatria social, representando uma das principais alternativas ao regime de internamento completo. O conceito de Hospital de Dia em psiquiatria foi criado na ex-urss em1930, expandindo-se para os EUA durante os anos 40 e 50, e atingindo o seu auge na década de Apesar de se ter registado nas décadas seguintes um declínio da sua expansão e encerramento significativos, nos últimos anos tem surgido um interesse renovado que foi traduzido num aumento do número de Hospitais de Dia. Embora este facto possa estar relacionado com evidência de eficácia ao nível do custo-benefício, benefícios sociais, e prestação eficaz de cuidados, o surgimento de novos paradigmas como o atendimento domiciliar podem fazêlo parecer antiquado. Actualmente, os seus programas de tratamento integrados num moderno sistema de cuidados de saúde mental comunitária, definem-se por uma intensificação e diversificação de modelos terapêuticos aplicados a diferentes perturbações psiquiátricas. Contudo, a heterogeneidade dos programas na comunidade que a designação de Hospital Dia engloba, pode todavia dificultar a avaliação da sua eficácia. Os autores pretendem com a presente revisão bibliográfica esclarecer a posição do Hospital de Dia no contexto actual e futuro dos cuidados de saúde mentais. PALAVRAS-CHAVE: HOSPITAL DE DIA; PSIQUIATRIA COMUNITÁRIA; SAÚDE MENTAL 1. Clínica de Psiquiatria e Saúde Mental, Centro Hospitalar de São João 2. Departamento de Neurociências Clínicas e Saúde Mental, Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade do Porto INTRODUCTION Today we are assisting to the deinstitutionalization of Psychiatry and Mental Health with the disappearance of the traditional psychiatric hospital known as an asylum system. This was impelled by a change of paradigm in social and community policies and ideals with concerns on a closer supervision of patients within the local community. The day hospital is among some of the earliest forms of community and social psychiatry. Community care is expected to involve general practitioners and various public or private institutions to develop a network that will enable the sharing of knowledge regarding psychiatric disorders and therapeutic care. As an alternative to both inpatient and outpatient treatment of acute, short-stay and some chronic psychiatric selected patients, it disposes most of the treatment normally available to inpatients, giving an emphasis to social and therapeutic groups. It contributes to the progressive readaptation to life in the community, keeping the patient's place in the family and promoting the chance of individual freedom and individuals identity. 1 Despite the growth of community care programs, many individuals with acute psychiatric disorders continue to be treated as inpatients, 2 with additional treatment costs. Rationalization is necessary to realize the advantages of day hospital care and to minimize the dangers of institutionalisation, 7 as patients are sometimes isolated in hospital more often and for longer than it would be necessary. HISTORY The first reported day hospital was established in Moscow, ex-urss, by M. A. Dzhagarov, in 1933, to reduce the duration of inpatient admission in a context of inadequate funds; it consisted mostly of occupational therapy. 3,4 In the Western countries, the first one was born in Montreal in 1946, as part of a psychiatric teaching hospital, the Allan Memorial Institute, again in an attempt to reduce the demand for inpatient beds. Soon after, in the USA, a partial hospital program was established in 1948 at Yale, at the Menninger Clinic. In 1949 was settled another one in Kansas, and in 1952 at the Massachusetts Mental Health Centre. 4 As the notions of therapeutic community expanded after the Second World War and better ways of dealing with psychiatric disorders evolved due to the advent of psychodrugs, it became apparent that the community needed a site where, discharged patients could be treated without formal inpatient admission. 5,6 They became popular in the 1960 s after the setting up of partial hospitali- 2012;26[1]: ARTIGO 219 zation program directed by the Community Mental Health Center Construction Act in In Europe, they also spread during the 1940s and 1950s, reaching their peak in the 1970s, when provided the main alternative for hospital admission. 7 In 1948, it was established the first one in England, a social club at the Social Psychiatry Centre in London. Then, a number of other such settings followed, and by 1959 existed more than 38. The movement incorporated Bierer s philosophy: treatment must include the whole social environment of the patient and all his social relationships. [The patient] must be treated not only as a person but as part of a community, written in the Lancet in 1959 (p. 901). 6 There were community ideals favoring unrestricted and open communication, a culture of inquiry and group therapies. Similar developments reached the Netherlands and West Germany in the 1970s. 8,9 At that time there was a rapid growth and expansion across Europe and USA. However, during the eighties and nineties, that exponential grow was followed by a widespread closure and investment reduction on partial hospitalization programs, 10,11 associated with the emerging evidence of limited cost-effectiveness, 12,13 a rise in costs and certain undefinition concerning treatment concepts (clinical population, the purpose of hospitalization and inappropriately length of stay). 14,15 Finally, day hospitals started to face competition from more radical non-institutional alternatives such as assertive community treatment 24 and acute home based care. These alternatives made them appear old fashioned, stigmatizing and expensive. 16 Notwithstanding all these facts, in the late years, evidence is demonstrating effectiveness associated with emerging social trends built in a psychiatric reform context. An increasing proportion of psychiatric patients are being treated in day hospital settings By 1999, at Germany, with the expansion described, there were 273 day hospitals, 40 against the 60 settled in the beginning of eighties, 21 and typically started not to be located on hospital grounds or not to belong to a psychiatric department. 30,46 Also, at England it was reported by 2004 the existence of 102 acute day hospitals. 22 In Poland it was expected an increase in the number of day hospitals, from 56 in 1985 to 430 in DAY HOSPITAL SETTINGS AND TREATMENTS CONCEPTS In the past several decades various types of partial hospitalization programs have been developed with the purpose of offering either an effective alternative to hospital admission or an intermediate step after an inpatient stay. Day treatment signifies the absence of night-time as it covers the whole day (e.g. 9 to 4 pm) in 5-7 days a week. Although considered by many authors as a continuum, there seems to be some heterogeneity in the different partial hospitalization or day care programs such as, transitional care for patients leaving hospital, more intensive alternatives to outpatient care (day treatment programs), and support of long-term patients living in the community (day care centers). 23,24,81 Day hospital as partial hospitalization program has a dynamic structure: it can provide diagnostic and treatment services for acutely ill patients who would otherwise be treated on traditional psychiatric inpatient units, it can offer treatment for patients experiencing some degree of remission from acute illness, and it can provide maintenance and rehabilitation for chronic psychiatric illness. 25 This is accomplished by integrating pharmacological, psychotherapeutic and sociotherapeutic treatment integrated in multidimensional service including as well crisis intervention. 30 In other words, as Shek et al. defined, is an ambulatory treatment program that includes the major diagnostic, medical, psychiatric, psychosocial, and pre-vocational treatment modalities designed for people with serious mental disorders which require co-ordinated, intensive, comprehensive, and multi-disciplinary treatment not provided in an outpatient clinic setting facilities . 82 Globally, the objective is to reduce the impact of symptoms, providing emotional support, encouraging social connection, and restoring working capacities. Family members also receive psychological support in supportive groups for families and patients. As multidisciplinary day care facilities, they can offer a diversity of treatment programs, with different ideologies, goals, target populations, intensity and duration, 26 suitable for regional needs 27 as occurs in the Netherlands 28 and UK. 29 Marshall et al, differentiate four types of day hospital s programme structure: (1) acute psychiatric day hospitals as alternative to admission for acute disorders, (2) transitional day hospitals for shortening admission of patients recently discharged from inpatient care, (3) day care centers for rehabilitation or maintenance of long-term disorders, and (4) day treatment programs as intensive alternative to outpatient care. 35 The treatment programs are determined according the aims and objectives established by therapeutic orientations on a psychotherapeutic basis, depending this on the type mental disorder designated. 30 The question that emerges is if these are or not similar, although the wide spectrum of mental disorders, 2012;26[5]: 220 ARTIGO how can it be traduced in structural and procedural differences? A recent survey by Seidler KP et al. in Germany studied the different therapeutic orientations and found that patients characteristics were the main determinants of the differences in treatment programs. Like Marshall et al. differentiate four types of day hospital programs these authors went further in the definition and proposed that it can be specified as three main areas of function (rehabilitation, psychotherapy, crisis intervention) and four therapeutic orientations (psychodynamic, sociotherapeutic, psychodynamic social psychiatric, behavioral social psychiatric). 30 They described the rehabilitative orientated day hospitals by more weekend offers and more occupational therapy; between those with psychotherapeutic function and those with crisis intervention the differences are defined mainly by structural characteristics being the first ones more often institutionally affiliated. 28 In turn, the psychodynamically orientated day hospitals offer more psychotherapeutic group as well team sessions, and the behavioral social psychiatric orientated have a special concern for individual related work with relatives. The sociotherapeutic orientated offer lesser places for treatment than psychodynamic social orientated, being predominantly located on hospital grounds. They also found as a majority the social psychiatric based orientation combined with psychodynamic or behavioral concepts. They concluded that there were no differences relative to some structural features (such as costs of care, number of employees and rooms), acute crisis beds, diagnosis-specific therapeutic offers and suicidal attempts. 28 DAY HOSPITAL OR INPATIENT CARE? Fifty years of controversy seems to arise in comparing the costs between day hospital and inpatient care. At the beginning of the 70 s a greater emphasis was placed on partial hospitalization programs, 31 but after limited evidence of cost-effectiveness it was verified to a partial closure of such programs. Meanwhile this tendency reverted once again as recent findings showed that a combination of both, as complementing or following each other, may be an appropriate therapeutic approach. 32 In many retrospective studies, day hospital has been as effective as inpatient treatment, 8,33,34,37,38 and appeared superior in terms of reducing psychopathology in the short term and also in the prevention and reduction of readmission, 5,34,40 a finding not shown for any other alternative to admission. A systematic review found that treatment in day hospitals led to cost reductions ranging from 20,9% to 36,9% over inpatient care, being generally cheaper and associated with greater treatment satisfaction than inpatient treatment. 35 Further, a recent update of this systemic review concluded that caring for people in acute day hospitals can achieve substantial reduction in the numbers of people needing inpatient care, whilst improving patient outcome. 84 Creed et al. also found similar findings, being the running costs of a 30 place day hospital roughly one third of those of a 30 bedded ward, as a consequence of, for example, only one nursing shift. 36 Kallert et al. demonstrated a cost reduction of 22%, 37 and others authors have reached the same conclusions Also, there is an improving of social functioning, 8 reduction of family burden, 7-43 and reduction of relapse rates, 44 and a greater subjective quality of life compared to the inpatient group at time of discharge. However, more recently, Priebe et al. found a mean of 55,7 days compared with a mean of 30,5 days of inpatient care, 40 and so, finding higher costs. But, again, these generated better patient outcomes than other services, produced a more effective reduction of psychopathology and higher patient satisfaction. 40 A recent multicenter randomized controlled trial for establishing the effectiveness of acute day hospital care in a large sample across a range of mental health care systems, concluded that day hospital care is as effective on clinical outcomes as conventional inpatient care and more effective on social outcomes. 45 Nevertheless, as Priebe et al. found, a possible reason for admission to acute treatment on a conventional ward rather than a day hospital may be the greater severity of symptoms. 85 Interestingly, they also found that female gender and higher literacy patients seem to benefit more from acute treatment in day hospitals. 85 SPECIALIZED DAY HOSPITALS Day hospitals specialized in certain mental disorders do exist, and in Europe, approximately one third are predominantly psychotherapeutic, addressing mainly personality disorders. 46 These patients are, in recent years, being treated in day hospitals with a more psychodynamically orientation. A controlled randomized trial comparing short-term day hospital psychotherapy and outpatient individual therapy for moderate to severe personality disorders found a modest general improvement in a broad range of clinical measures. However, for the most severely ill patients it was no superior. 47 For borderline personality disorder there are better defined programs and results compared to others persona- 2012;26[1]: ARTIGO 221 lity disorders. 83,48,79 A dialectic behavioral therapy 49 has been applied but do not reach the same good results than the mentalization based-treatment programs of Bateman and Fonagy, especially for patients with more severe disease. 50,51 This was applied in 18 months of duration, as the first phase of a long term treatment strategy followed by a outpatient treatment. 49 Avoidant personality disorder patients didn t respond so well to day treatment 52,53 and need individual psychotherapy supplementing group therapy. 80 In the elderly, day hospitals are, together with adult day centers and in-home care, valuable alternatives to the full-time family caregiver, the nursing home, community mental health teams, 1 and psychiatric hospitalization. It permits a long term monitoring both for patients and their careers in the community addressing psychological distress, memory impairment and daytime activities. It can offers intensive assessment, treatment and rehabilitation for functional disorders, depression and dementia. 61,62 There is evidence of significant reduction of anxiety and apathy, a better adhesion to therapeutic community treatment, 63 lower costs and delay nursing home placements in patients with dementia, a progressive improvement in the clinical state and higher adhesion to community and group treatment in moderate depressive elderly patients. 60 Patients with mood disorders are more often admitted to intensive biopsychosocial day hospital programs. A research performed in Italy to determine the effectiveness of an intensive short-term day hospital program showed a significant improvement among depressed patients with comorbid dysthymic disorder, particularly if accompanied by acute stress or crisis. 69 Those with comorbid personality disorder showed more moderate improvement. However, there is inconsistency towards the improvements on psychopathology and more primary research on the efficacy is needed. 35,70 Anxiety disorder is also adequately treated in a psychotherapeutically orientated day hospital, focusing on crisis intervention for current conflicts, especially if a more intense psychotherapy as provided in an outpatient setting is needed or if inpatient setting is not adequate. 30,80 There is recent evidence of better results for partial day hospitalization programs compared to outpatient treatment on patients with eating disorders. 71,72 A day hospital placed in a community setting can provide for patients with anorexia nervosa the advantages of reducing the stigma of being treated in a psychiatric hospital and also of containing parents fears of their siblings exposure to individuals with severe psychiatric illness. In perinatal disorders, as post-partum depression, day hospital can provide a full range of interventions (motherhood classes, anxiety management, occupational therapy, etc.) with minimal family disruption, giving highly anxious mothers the opportunity to gain experience allowing others to care for the infant. In a study of 5 years settled in a mother-baby day hospital with cognitive-behaviour and interpersonal therapy, the authors found effectiveness in reducing the depressive symptoms, higher level of satisfaction and cost savings of approximately 50% in comparison to traditional inpatient treatment. 73,74 Day hospital may reduce the negative consequences of inpatient care for suicidal patients, like loss of freedom, regression and hopeless and forced admission. 75,76 Mazza M et al. developed a day hospital program to manage suicidal ideation and suicidal behaviour integratin
Related Search
Similar documents
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks